33. Phil Simms
SI once named him the most underrated QB of all time. Simms led the Giants to 2 SB wins as a 2x pro-bowler. He was also named all-pro once. His performance in 1987 SB XXI was legendary with an 88% pass completion (22/25) and 150.9 passer rating, it was the best QB performance in SB history.
Advertisement